Share this post

Pizza Wars 2015: Wooden Peel named best in northern Indiana

Six weeks and more than 100,000 votes later, northern Indiana has spoken. 

Pizza Wars came to a close as Marshall County’s Wooden Peel was voted the best pizza in northern Indiana, according to a news release from the Northern Indiana Tourism Development Commission (NITDC). 

Wooden Peel (108 W. Plymouth St., Bremen) faced off in the championship round with Kosciusko County’s Cafe at The Bowling Alley. The votes were close, with Wooden Peel garnering 51 percent of the votes and Cafe at The Bowling Alley rallying 49 percent, according to the Pizza Wars voting bracket

When the final eight pizzerias were selected, NITDC brought food critic and journalist Kate Silver to sample each of the final eight pizzas, according to previous Flavor 574 reporting: 

Silver chose Iechyd Da (317 N. Main St., Elkhart) as the Critic’s Choice winner and The Cafe at The Bowling Alley (1535 N. Detroit St., Warsaw) got honorable mention, according to the news release. 

After trying each pizza, Silver scored each slice based on crust, sauce, cheese, toppings, ambiance/history and execution, according to the release. At Iechyd Da, she tried the Kidwelly, inspired by owners Chip and Summer Lewis’ travels, and even tucked into a second piece. 


“There’s a thoughtfulness that comes through in every bite of Iechyd Da’s pizza — the aroma, the flavors, the textures,” she said in the release. “But the pizza doesn’t just taste incredible. It tells a story about the owners, their travels and the town of Elkhart. It starts a conversation.”

See what Silver had to say about each of the eight finalists on her blog, and relive the fun of the competition with the tag #PizzaWarsNI

Follow digital producer Danielle Waldron on Twitter @DanielleWaldron

Type and hit enter